Former Disney CEO
Michael Eisner abjectly apologized for this film, calling it “s stupid mistake.”
On bended knee, he groveled to the Chinese Communist Party (CCP): “The bad news
is the film was made; the good news is nobody watched it.” Disney saw to that.
The film in question was directed by Martin Scorsese, who dedicated it to his
recently deceased mother, Catherine. It was also nominated for four Academy
Awards, including Philip Glass’s justly celebrated score. However, you can’t
stream Scorsese’s cinematic biography of the 14th (and according to him,
last) Dalai Lama. Again, Disney made the conscious decision to keep it out of
circulation. Hence any screening of Scorsese’s Kundun is a big deal, so
its special screening to celebrate Scorsese’s birthday at the 2025 Tribeca Film Festival is a huge event.
Born Lhamo
Thondup, the Dalai Lama was a rather willful child, but also an intelligent
one. Reting, the Regent of Tibet quickly realizes the bright little boy should
be tested to determine whether he is the reincarnated spiritual leader of
Tibetan Buddhists, which indeed turns out to be the case.
As the
recognized Dalai Lama studies at Potala Palace, he shows a keen curiosity
regarding the outside world. That will be just as well, because the outside
world soon barges into Tibet. Unfortunately, after the devastation of WWII,
England and Europe are too exhausted to intervene when China invades and
annexes Tibet. Likewise, the newly independent India is too disorganized and
America is too far. Consequently, the Dalai Lama and his ministers agree to
negotiate with Mao.
However,
many of the senior Lamas realize they are really only stalling for time, even though
the Dalai Lama still hopes for a more equitable and autonomous arrangement.
Sadly, as the CCP starts razing monasteries, the Dalai Lama recognizes the CCP
as the oppressors they always intended to be. Nevertheless, he resists seeking
sanctuary in India, because he refuses to abandon his people when they need him
the most.
It is
easy to see why Kundun (the Tibetans’ term of reverence and affection
for the Dalai Lama, meaning “the Presence”) angered the CCP. First of all, it
is an excellent film, unlike the junky rom-coms and stilted propaganda movies
the Chinese film industry now cranks out. It also forthrightly depicts the brutality
and destruction of the CCP occupation. Yet, it is small but telling moments,
like when the Dalai Lama bemoans the blaring bombastic Chinese propaganda music,
lamenting: “they even took our silence,” that are especially devastating.
Indeed,
Scorsese and screenwriter Melissa Mathison follow the historical record, depicting
the Dalai Lama as neither a rebel nor a hot-head. He was a remains a man of
non-violence, who was forced into a painful exile, as a means of preserving the
Tibetan national soul.
Despite
the tragedy it captures, Kundun is a gorgeous film, magnificently lensed
by acclaimed cinematographer Roger Deakins. He and Scorsese use the colors and
imagery of the Tibetan sand mandala to arresting effect. Glass’s score is hypnotic,
but it also expresses a sense of awe. Just in terms of technical artistry, Kundun
is unusually accomplished.