Like Viktor Frankl, Herbert Heller saw the worst of humanity in concentration camps, but chose to live. Generally speaking, he similarly values both freedom and responsibility. However, he has kept his Holocaust survival story a long-festering secret, even from his family, out of survivor’s guilt. He lived, while others didn’t. Yet, Heller finally starts telling his story, despite the pain, when he realizes a troubled teen needs to hear it in director-screenwriter Finn Taylor’s The Optimist (formerly Avenue of the Giants), which releases today on VOD.
After receiving a grim prognosis from his doctor, Heller realizes, if he is ever going to tell his story, it might very well be now or never. With the help of an oral history nonprofit, Heller connects with Ruth, a counselor who previously interviewed several survivors. She largely stepped away from such work, but she had a hunch recording Heller might have a positive impact on her latest patient, Abby.
Abby is a rather troubled teen, but she is not a bad kid. In fact, Heller knows she is troubled, because he saw her in the hospital. It was sort of what you’re thinking, but more complicated. Regardless, Heller quickly opens up to Abby and she soaks up his story like a sponge. Soon, she is independently researching subjects like the composer Viktor Ullmann, whom Heller heard perform in Terezin, the sanitized camp the National Socialists created to deceive the Red Cross. However, Heller ill-advisedly requested a transfer to Auschwitz to remain with his family—a decision he quickly regretted.
Many of Heller’s so-called “secrets” simply represent the tough but necessary choices he made to survive. They weren’t even “Sophie’s Choices,” but they still caused a lifetime of guilt. Abby will try to convince Heller to forgive himself—and vice versa.
The Optimist is a perfect example of why Stephen Lang should be more widely recognized as a national treasure. His performance as Heller is acutely sensitive, but it also has grit. You absolutely believe this man is a survivor. Likewise, Luke David Blumm is quite remarkable as the young flashback Heller. It is often difficult watching him as he loses his naivete and innocence, but these scenes consistently ring true.
